But not on the right thing.
Far too often I’m sat with my organic mug of cocoa being forced by Mrs. FAIR* to watch some turgid nonsense like The X Factor, or Dancing with the stars or other acts against humanity. Now, believe it or not, this has got me thinking about something interesting.
Constantly throughout these shows you hear the same phrase used from both sides - the people trying to live our their dream, and from the judges pushing them on. There’s no doubting that everyone says they’re “working hard”, and that they need to “keep on working hard”. If everyone keeps on working hard then everything will be ok.
Actually, I think this says a lot about the mentality of the people on these shows, because working hard isn’t good enough.
In the educational system here in the UK, working hard is applauded, but achievement is rewarded. Certainly in the Higher Educational system I’m part of, working hard is expected as a prerequisite. It means pretty much nothing. What is important is making the right choices. If you choose well, if you make the right choices on where you’re going to apply that effort then you’re on the right path. Simply working hard is not good enough.
Maybe I’m thinking too much into it - I probably am - but I think that this mindset needs to change. If we presume that the majority of the viewers for these shows will be younger people (not all, but the majority), then I think there’s actually an obligation on the makers to make it explicit that working hard isn’t enough, and that a level above that needs to be achieved in order to strive towards their goal.
For me it’s the same argument as knowledge and intelligence. Anyone can learn stuff, anyone can take information in and store it, but it’s the application of that knowledge at the right time that leads to intelligence… in my eyes at least. What we’ll end up with if the educational system was based on The X Factor would be a society full of surface learners, when what we’re looking for is a society full of deep learners.
We can discuss the merits of rewarding effort over rewarding achievement (and trust me, I’ve discussed it a lot), but the fact remains that hard work doesn’t make you brilliant at anything. Knowing what to work hard on does.